This article was originally published on Crafting Your Home. A human contributor also wrote and edited the post.
Manhattan’s most expensive housing tier posted its weakest week since late December. Only one residence asking more than $10 million entered into a contract between July 6 and July 12, 2026. The slowdown arrived days after a new city surcharge began applying to certain high-value homes that are not primary residences.
One trophy deal survives.
The week produced only one trophy contract above $10 million. That deal involved a condominium at 1122 Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side, listed for $21.8 million.
The next most expensive signed contract involved a Chelsea condominium asking slightly less than $10 million. Twenty of the 29 luxury deals had asking prices below $6 million, indicating stronger demand at the lower end of the high-end market.
Brokers typically see three to five contracts above $10 million during an ordinary week. Summer often slows Manhattan sales, but the latest total fell below the seasonal pace described by several market professionals.
Brokers point to caution.
Some brokers linked the pause to uncertainty surrounding taxes and the city’s treatment of wealthy second-home owners. Buyers considering eight-figure properties often review recurring costs with lawyers, accountants, and investment advisers before signing.
That concern does not prove wealthy households are leaving New York. One week offers a narrow sample, and similar weakness has appeared in the Hamptons, where many Manhattan owners also maintain homes.
Strong Wall Street compensation and technology wealth may continue supporting demand. The latest numbers could instead show buyers shifting toward properties below $10 million, where annual ownership costs remain lower.
New surcharge targets second homes
The new tax took effect on July 1. It applies to qualifying high-value residences that are not primary homes. The Department of Finance will determine which properties fall under the rules.
The law treats property types differently. Condominiums and co-ops use assessed values, while one- to three-family homes use market values. Rates rise through several value brackets.
A property can avoid the surcharge when it qualifies as the primary residence of an owner or certain immediate family members. A qualifying long-term tenant may also satisfy the occupancy requirement.
Homes held through trusts, partnerships, or limited liability companies can still be subject to review. Officials may examine ownership, residency, and lease information before issuing a final determination.
Owners can challenge a classification and submit documents supporting an exemption. That process may include tax filings, identification, utility bills, voting information, or a valid lease.
Earlier demand remained strong.
The weak week followed a solid second quarter for Manhattan luxury housing. Signed contracts above $5 million increased 5% from the same period last year, while deals above $3 million rose 17%.
Average marketing time fell to 115 days. Active listings also declined, limiting choices for buyers seeking rare penthouses, park views, or newly built residences.
That earlier strength complicates claims that the market has entered a broad collapse. Some buyers may have completed deals before July 1 to avoid uncertainty over the new surcharge.
Revenue projections remain uncertain.
City officials included the surcharge in plans to strengthen New York’s finances. The tax could raise $500 million annually before exemptions and changes in owner behavior reduce collections.
A separate estimate placed possible revenue between $340 million and $380 million after accounting for rentals, exemptions, and taxpayer responses. Owners could establish primary residency, lease properties, appeal valuations, or sell.
Those choices could affect both city revenue and Manhattan prices. Buyers may subtract several years of expected tax payments from their offers, especially for properties used only a few weeks each year.
Sellers and developers may respond with closing credits, paid common charges, or other incentives. Older homes with high maintenance bills could face the greatest pressure because the surcharge adds another recurring expense.
The next weekly contract totals will show whether the trophy-market pause extends beyond mid-July. The Department of Finance must also finalize implementation details and notify owners who will be subject to the new charge.
For now, Manhattan’s broader luxury market continues producing deals. The clearest weakness remains concentrated above $10 million, where buyers have the most flexibility and the largest potential tax exposure.
If you like what you just read, then subscribe to our newsletter and follow us on social media
