A chewed-up shoe sits in the hallway, and a dog stands beside it with ears pinned back and eyes fixed on the floor. To most owners the message is obvious: somebody knows exactly what happened. According to the American Kennel Club, that reading is almost certainly wrong.
The AKC’s training experts say the bond between people and dogs can feel so close that it seems each can read the other’s mind, but dogs do not behave, react or process information the way people do. Six everyday behaviors get misread more than others, and a few of them are habits that owners have practiced with love for years.
Hugs and Head Pats: Misreads 1 and 2
1. Hugging. Many owners assume a dog that holds still for a hug is happy. The AKC says many dogs yawn or lick their lips during a hug, pin their ears back or show the whites of their eyes, all signs of discomfort or anxiety, and that the dog is most likely tolerating the hug, not delighting in it. Psychology professor Stanley Coren put numbers on it in a Psychology Today post: he examined the first 250 photos of people hugging dogs from Google Images and Flickr searches, and 81.6% of the dogs (204 of 250) showed at least one sign of stress or anxiety. For more on what dogs do mean by closeness, here are nine reasons a dog leans on its owner, and Frenz Hub’s list of things humans do that dogs hate covers similar ground.
Among the signs Coren listed were turning the head away or avoiding eye contact, partly closing the eyes, “whale eye” or “half-moon eye” where the whites show, ears lowered or pressed flat, lip licking, yawning and raising one paw. Only 7.6% of the dogs appeared relaxed, and 10.8% looked neutral or unclear. The AKC suggests better ways to show affection, including leaning against the dog, allowing it to rest its head on a lap, or simply spending time in the same room. Dogs show a lot with little movements, as these five reasons a dog stares suggest, and Frenz Hub offers a look at getting a home guest-ready with a pet.
2. Head pats. It is a natural human impulse to reach down and pat a dog’s head, and the AKC says some dogs find it uncomfortable. Signs of avoidance include lowering the head, stepping or ducking away, anxiety-driven yawning or lip-licking, ears back and whale eye. The advice for meeting an unfamiliar dog is to let the dog approach, offer a hand low or kneel to the dog’s level, and treat a lean as a likely welcome. A sigh can say plenty too, as these six reasons a dog sighs show, and Frenz Hub’s piece on self-cleaning litter boxes speaks to life with pets at home.
The Chewed Shoe and the Guilty Look: Misreads 3 and 4
3. Destructive behavior, accidents and barking read as spite. Coming home to chewed furniture or an accident on the floor feels personal. The AKC says dogs tend to live in the moment and do not plot payback. Chances are, they are bored or have been alone too long, since dogs need mental and physical stimulation and some breeds crave human contact more than others. Destructive behavior can occasionally signal separation anxiety, which the AKC says needs training or veterinary intervention. Barking at the door is a common complaint, and Frenz Hub’s front-door camera picks look at keeping an eye on a busy entry. The same logic explains the guilty look, which this explainer on why dogs do not actually feel guilty also covers.
4. The guilty look. The AKC’s guide says the so-called guilty look is most likely fear. Dogs may respond to an owner’s posture and tone with typical anxiety signals: whale eye, cowering, sudden lip-licking or yawning and ears pinned back. They may display this look even when they have done nothing wrong, and the response is often triggered by the owner’s behavior, not any sense of wrongdoing. Scientific American describes research by Alexandra Horowitz in which the guilty look appeared mainly when owners scolded, and not when dogs had actually eaten a forbidden treat. Dogs scolded for a treat they had not eaten showed the most exaggerated look.
Excuses and Puppy Habits: Misreads 5 and 6
5. Excusing behavior such as growling in the lap. If a dog sits in a lap and growls or snaps at anyone who comes close, it is tempting to call it cute or assume the dog is just protecting its owner. The AKC says that is a behavior issue that needs attention. A dog that jumps excitedly on everyone who enters the house falls into the same category. Clear boundaries and consistent expectations are key, and the payoff is a calmer, more confident dog.
6. Puppy habits such as begging. Puppies are adorable, and it is easy to see their behavior as cute antics. According to the AKC, if a puppy learns that begging for food earns a treat, or that growling at visitors is treated like a trick, the habit will not simply fade with age. Those behaviors continue unless the dog is trained not to. The good news, per the AKC, is that most puppies are highly receptive to training, and the earlier consistent boundaries are in place, the easier it tends to be for everyone.
The bond between people and dogs is undeniable, and a little translation helps. Dogs can love as much as their owners do, but they are not human, and learning to read their body language makes the relationship easier and more rewarding.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Crafting Your Home.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: PROPOLI87 – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
