A bank vault sounds like the safest place in town, which is exactly why so many families park their most important papers there and forget about them. The trouble shows up later, when a bank is closed, an owner has died or a document is needed on a Saturday night.
According to AARP, only items that are expensive or difficult, if not impossible, to replace belong in a safe deposit box, and several everyday items fail that test. Seven things are better kept at home or elsewhere, from the original will to spare keys, along with advice from an estate attorney and a safe deposit consultant on what to do instead.
A Box Protects Against Theft but Not Against Delay
Dave McGuinn, founder and president of the consulting firm Safe Deposit Specialist, told AARP that a box makes the most sense for anything hard to replace, sentimental or meant to be passed on to children, because family members know where it is. The same article warns that boxes come with access limits, especially in emergencies or when the bank is closed.
The idea of what to keep where is part of a bigger conversation about getting affairs in order, as in the post on things estate attorneys say should never be written into a will. For a broader look at regrets that come from skipping the paperwork, the roundup of common regrets people experience in adulthood makes a useful companion, and the look back at little rituals from the 80s and 90s that disappeared is a lighter detour.
Items 1 and 2: The Original Will and Powers of Attorney
1. The original will. A box might seem logical for a will, but AARP notes that if the owner is the sole signer on the box, an executor could face legal obstacles after the owner’s death. According to the American Bankers Association, banks usually need a court order to open a box once the owner has died, which slows down settling an estate. AARP’s alternative is a fireproof home safe, with the location and combination shared with someone trusted, or the original kept at the law firm that drafted it. Keeping key papers in one trusted spot is one of those long-held habits, much like the boomer habits that are making a comeback. Brinks Home gives similar advice, adding that executors should be named in the document if it must go to the bank.
2. Powers of attorney. A financial or health care power of attorney is only helpful if someone can reach it when needed. Estate-planning attorney Naomi Becker Collier told AARP that a power of attorney is no longer valid once the owner dies, so it should not be locked where it cannot be retrieved. The suggested fix is to give a copy to an attorney or family member and keep an original somewhere secure at home. The site’s guide to what never to do with a parent’s bank account after death shows how quickly access becomes a problem for families. The post on gaps senior citizens wish they had covered touches on the planning side.
Items 3 to 5: Passports, Cash and Spare Keys
3. A passport or other ID. Anyone who travels often or needs identification quickly may find a bank vault inconvenient, especially after hours. Brinks Home makes a similar point, listing passports and Social Security cards among the items it says belong in a home safe because banks are not open around the clock. A home safe or another secure, easy-to-reach spot works better. Travelers can also browse the roundup of travel accessories for ways to keep documents handy, and couples deciding where the papers should live can start with nine money conversations married couples avoid.
4. Cash. Cash is the clearest case. The FDIC states that the contents of a safe deposit box are not insured by the FDIC, and that the rental contract should be read to see whether the bank provides any other insurance, since some banks make a very limited payment if the box or contents are damaged or destroyed. AARP notes that most banks recommend against keeping cash in boxes and, citing the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, points to an account, a prepaid card or a home safe as alternatives.
5. Spare keys. Backup keys are most useful when something goes wrong outside banking hours, and AARP notes that retrieving them from a box is impractical in that case. Its advice is to give a spare to a trusted friend or relative or keep one in a secure lockbox at home.
Items 6 and 7: Uninsured Jewelry and Restricted Items
6. Uninsured jewelry. Heirloom pieces are good candidates for a box, but AARP warns that without insurance, plumbing disasters and natural disasters remain a risk. McGuinn suggests asking an insurance agent about adding a personal articles floater and telling the insurer that the items are in a box, which could mean a premium discount of about 50 percent. The FDIC likewise suggests considering fire and theft insurance, which usually comes as part of a homeowner’s or tenant’s policy.
7. Illegal or restricted items. Firearms, explosives and illicit substances may violate bank policies or legal rules if stored in a box, McGuinn told AARP. Banks do not check contents, but that does not make the restriction any less real. AARP’s alternative for firearms is a secure, locked safe at home.
What a Safe Deposit Box Is Still Good For
None of this means the box is obsolete. Brinks Home says items such as a grandmother’s engagement ring, the deed to a home, birth certificates and car titles belong in the bank, and it points to the FDIC in saying that savings bonds not yet converted to electronic securities should be stored there too. AARP’s list of best contents includes adoption records, armed service records, citizenship papers, death certificates, marriage and divorce records, property records and insured jewelry.
AARP adds that no box or home safe is completely protected from theft, fire, flood or other loss, and that placing valuables in plastic bags or containers labeled with the owner’s name is recommended by the FDIC. It also suggests telling someone where the box is and, if the owner trusts that person enough, adding them to the contract so they can reach the contents without legal headaches if something happens to the owner.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Crafting Your Home.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Photo by Joe Mabel – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons
