This article was originally published on Crafting Your Home. A human contributor also wrote and edited the post.
America looked back across two and a half centuries and found Donald Trump standing at both ends of its national story.
In a YouGov survey conducted around the United States’ 250th anniversary, 34% of respondents selected Trump as the worst American of the past 250 years. That was the largest share received by any of the nine people included in the final question.
But the survey delivered an extraordinary contradiction. Trump also finished fifth on the list of the greatest Americans, receiving 8% of the vote. Among Republican respondents, he ranked first, with 24% naming him the greatest American in the country’s history.
The result gives Trump a title few political figures could carry. To one part of the country, he represents strength, disruption and a refusal to surrender.
To another, he represents division, democratic decline, and the aggressive politics they believe have transformed the nation for the worse. Trump did not simply appear in the survey. He dominated its emotional center.
The title is dramatic, but the numbers require context
Calling Trump the “worst American” is undeniably striking. However, the poll found that a majority of Americans did not agree with that description. Instead, 34% was the largest single share among the choices presented. That makes the result a plurality, not a national consensus.
The distinction matters. Nearly two-thirds of respondents selected someone else or did not choose Trump. The survey therefore does not show that America has collectively reached a settled judgment about him. It shows that Trump elicits stronger negative reactions than any other person on the final list.
His nearest competitor for the worst-American designation was convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein, who received 14%. Former President Barack Obama and serial killer Jeffrey Dahmer each received 8%.
That comparison makes Trump’s position even more politically explosive. He was not being measured only against rival presidents. Respondents were judging him alongside people associated with notorious crimes and some of the darkest chapters in American life.
Yet millions of Americans placed him above every Republican president, military commander, civil rights leader and national founder presented to them when asked to identify the country’s greatest figure. That is not a normal political reputation. It is a national fault line.
Democrats and Republicans are describing different Americas
The party breakdown reveals how the same political figure can carry entirely different meanings depending on who is speaking.
Among Democrats, 64% selected Trump as the worst American of the past 250 years. Among Republicans, only 4% did so. Republican respondents were more likely to choose Obama or former President Joe Biden for the negative distinction.
The pattern was reversed when respondents were asked to identify the greatest American. Trump received the highest share among Republicans, ahead of George Washington and Abraham Lincoln.
For many conservative voters, Trump is remembered as the president who challenged political institutions, tightened immigration enforcement, confronted foreign competitors and survived investigations, impeachments, criminal cases and an assassination attempt before returning to power.
His supporters do not always interpret the attacks against him as proof of wrongdoing. Many see those attacks as evidence that he challenged a political system determined to stop him.
His opponents reach the opposite conclusion. They point to his effort to overturn the 2020 election result, the attack on the U.S. Capitol, his confrontational language, and his continued pressure on political and legal institutions. Each side sees the other’s evidence. Each side reaches a completely different verdict.
Lincoln remains the closest thing to a shared national hero
While Trump produced the survey’s most dramatic result, Abraham Lincoln remained the country’s most broadly respected historical figure. Lincoln ranked first overall as the greatest American, receiving 18% of the responses. George Washington followed with 13%, Martin Luther King Jr. received 12%, Obama earned 10%, and Trump received 8%.
Lincoln also demonstrated something increasingly rare in American politics: significant admiration across party lines. He was selected by 19% of Democrats and 18% of Republicans.
Democrats were most likely to choose King or Obama. Republicans preferred Trump or Washington. Lincoln, however, remained competitive within both groups.
That cross-party respect suggests Americans may still agree on some chapters of their national history, even as they fight bitterly over the present.
Trump’s position is different. His reputation is powered by intensity rather than broad agreement. He does not unite Americans around a common interpretation. He forces them to choose a side.
How YouGov produced the unusual rankings
The findings came from a multistage research process rather than a single spontaneous question. YouGov initially asked open-ended questions about the people, achievements, failures and values Americans associate with the country’s history.
Researchers then used artificial intelligence to help identify the most frequently mentioned responses before presenting narrowed lists to later groups of participants.
The greatest and worst American findings were drawn from two online surveys conducted in late June 2026.
One included 1,110 adult U.S. citizens, while the other included 1,118. The samples were weighted using factors including age, race, education, gender, party identification, and previous voting behavior.
YouGov estimated a margin of error of approximately four percentage points for each survey. The method also creates an important limitation.
Respondents in the final stage were choosing from a prepared group of names, rather than selecting freely from every individual in American history.
The results therefore measure reactions to the finalists presented, not an unrestricted competition involving every American who has lived during the past 250 years.
Even with that qualification, Trump’s appearance near the top of both rankings remains revealing. When Americans were given the chance to express admiration or condemnation, his name drew both.
If you like what you just read, then subscribe to our newsletter and follow us on social media.
