The disappearance of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of “Today” show co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, has taken a strange turn nearly five months after she vanished from her Tucson-area home, and it’s the kind of update that answers one question while cracking open several new ones.
Federal investigators now believe the three ransom notes that dominated headlines for months, including the initial cryptocurrency demand, a follow-up claiming Nancy had died, and a more recent letter claiming to know the identities of her abductors, were not sent by whoever is actually responsible for her disappearance.
That’s a significant development on its own, but it doesn’t mean the case has cooled off or that authorities are any closer to bringing Nancy home. If anything, it means investigators are now working to strip away the noise so they can focus on whatever pieces of evidence might actually be real.
What the FBI Now Says About the Notes

The story broke Tuesday when an unnamed FBI official told Reuters that none of the ransom notes are believed to be genuine, speaking on condition of anonymity because the investigation remains active.
That official also said a second law enforcement source familiar with the case confirmed the same assessment, and that investigators determined the first two notes had originated from the same sender, though the specifics of how they reached that conclusion weren’t disclosed.
To test whether the very first note was legitimate, the FBI reportedly took an unusual step early in the investigation.
According to Reuters’ reporting, agents deposited a small amount of cryptocurrency into the account listed in the first ransom note to verify its authenticity and possibly trace it to the sender, but the funds were never used.
That detail alone tells you a lot about how deliberately investigators moved before going public with any of this.
That first note, according to details previously reported by TMZ, had demanded a payment described as being in the millions of dollars in cryptocurrency, with two separate payment deadlines set for February 5 and February 9.
A second note, which surfaced weeks later and stayed confidential for months at the request of law enforcement and the Guthrie family, was far darker.
It reportedly claimed Nancy had died shortly after being taken, was “buried in nature,” and stated that no ransom demand remained outstanding.
A third and more recent communication, sent separately to TMZ, claimed to know the identities of the people behind the kidnapping and to have video evidence involving what the sender called the “main guy” tied to the case.
The FBI has now dismissed all three as fabrications from people with no real connection to Nancy’s disappearance, which is obviously a relief in one sense but also a gut punch, because it means months of public anguish were, in part, fueled by hoaxers exploiting a grieving family’s desperation.
The FBI Walks It Back, Sort Of, and the Family Keeps Pleading for Answers
Here’s where the story gets more complicated, and where anyone following this case needs to pay close attention.
Barely a day after the Reuters report went out, the FBI’s Phoenix office pushed back on the idea that the entire investigation had been reduced to a pile of fake letters.
In a statement posted to X, the office said some of the notes have been deemed extortion attempts lacking legitimacy, while other ransom demands may be legitimate and are still being invest
