Relationships

In a Man’s World, a Feminist Is Either Masculine or Conventionally Unattractive

Pearl Oyando
By Pearl Oyando 7 min read

The post In a Man’s World, a Feminist Is Either Masculine or Conventionally Unattractive first appeared on Crafting Your Home.

Researchers at the University of Oslo tested whether feminist stereotypes operate below conscious thought. Participants viewed grayscale faces and guessed which ones belonged to feminists.

Women with square jaws and strong brows were consistently labeled feminist, and those same faces were rated as less warm and more threatening. Lead author Alexander Gundersen told Science Norway the strength of the results in our study surprised us. The study ran in one of the most gender equal countries on record, which makes the pattern harder to dismiss as regional bias.

Suffragists faced a similar stereotype a century earlier.

Annie Tinker drew attention in 1910s New York for wearing riding boots and a top hat, while anti-suffrage postcards portrayed single suffragists as unattractive, masculine spinsters, historian June Purvis has documented.

Suffrage leaders were consequently pressured to appear attractive and charming to counter the stereotype.

American women are still judged heavily through appearance

Image Credit: Flavia Jacquier/Pexels

A 2017 Pew Research Center survey found that 35% of Americans said society values physical attractiveness or beauty most in women. Another 30% pointed to nurturing and empathy.

The contrast with men was substantial. Only 11% said society values physical attractiveness most in men, while 33% named honesty or morality and 23% mentioned professional or financial success. The same Pew research found that 71% of Americans believed women faced a lot of pressure to be physically attractive, compared with only 27% who said the same about men.

That distinction matters because feminism challenges several traditional assumptions about what women are supposed to prioritize.

A woman can be ambitious, sexually autonomous, politically outspoken, financially independent and uninterested in pleasing men. Those characteristics have historically sat closer to qualities associated with masculinity in American cultural expectations.

Pew found that 28% of Americans believed women should not have traits associated with ambition, leadership or assertiveness. Only 5% identified strength or toughness as something women should not have, yet the broader pattern still showed a sharp divide between qualities associated with men and those associated with women.

The problem for feminism is obvious. A movement asking women to claim traits culturally reserved for men can easily be interpreted as asking women to become less feminine.

That interpretation is cultural. It is not a biological consequence of feminism.

The feminist-as-unattractive stereotype has actually been studied

Laurie Rudman and Kimberly Fairchild examined the relationship between feminism, beauty and romance in a series of studies published in Psychology of Women Quarterly in 2007.

Their findings are particularly relevant to the stereotype behind the headline. Participants did perceive beauty as being at odds with feminism, and the researchers found that the stereotype of feminists as unattractive was robust.

The researchers then examined why that stereotype existed.

Their findings linked the perception to assumptions surrounding heterosexual romance. In other words, the feminist-as-unattractive image was connected to beliefs about whether feminist women were compatible with conventional romantic expectations.

That distinction changes the story.

The research does not establish that feminism makes women unattractive. It shows that people can associate feminism with characteristics they believe conflict with conventional heterosexual femininity.

That is a social judgment about what feminism supposedly represents.

Masculinity becomes a label for women who reject feminine obedience

American ideas about masculinity and femininity have never been symmetrical.

Pew found that 53% of Americans believed society looks up to men who are manly or masculine. Only 32% said society looks up to feminine women to the same extent.

At the same time, women themselves reported a strong interest in being perceived as femini