Plenty of people think something kind about a stranger’s coat, a coworker’s presentation or a neighbor’s garden, and then say nothing. The hesitation feels like politeness or shyness. Research suggests it often comes from something more specific: a set of predictions about how the compliment will land, and those predictions tend to be wrong.
Studies by psychologists at Cornell, the University of Pennsylvania and the University of Chicago point to four common misjudgments. Each one makes a compliment feel riskier than it really is.
1. Underestimating How Much It Lifts the Recipient
The first error is about size. Erica Boothby and Vanessa Bohns reported in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin that compliment givers underestimated how positively recipients would feel. The paper, titled “Why a Simple Act of Kindness Is Not as Simple as It Seems,” is listed in Cornell University’s eCommons.
Psychologist Holly Parker, a lecturer at Harvard, summarized the work in a Psychology Today post. In the studies, participants gave strangers compliments, such as one about a shirt, and recipients generally appreciated them. One recipient wrote a note thanking the giver for making the day more human.
The same research found that giving a compliment improved the giver’s mood. A related read, eight compliments that can backfire, is a reminder that tone and context still matter, and a look at social norms that should be abandoned shows how many small habits rest on guesswork.
2. Overestimating How Awkward It Will Feel
The second misjudgment runs in the opposite direction. Boothby and Bohns found that givers overestimated how awkward or uncomfortable recipients would be, even after the fact, a worry that also hovers over six things never to do when staying with the in-laws and over hardest truths to accept in life. The Psi Chi blog post Misunderstanding the Power of Kindness reports the same pattern, noting that givers fear discomfort and social rejection more than the evidence warrants.
Cognitive scientist Art Markman, writing in Psychology Today, described a 2021 experiment by Xuan Zhao and Nicholas Epley published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. People who had known each other for almost ten years, on average, walked together in a park and were randomly assigned to write compliments or receive them. Givers overestimated how awkward the recipient would feel.
Etiquette habits can feed the same worry, as a list of social etiquette rules that Gen Z is done following shows, and so can traditions that confuse the rest of the world.
3. Underestimating How Good the Wording Sounds
The third misjudgment concerns phrasing. Markman reports that givers strongly underestimated how well-phrased recipients judged the compliment to be. Recipients cared far more about the sentiment than the exact words, a point that a guide to signs a partner truly cares makes about small, sincere gestures, as does a roundup of things that are often mistaken for rudeness.
That gap helps explain the freeze that sets in before speaking. Parker notes that givers tended to feel nervous and doubtful about their skill, which skewed their predictions, while observers who did not give compliments predicted recipients’ reactions more accurately than the givers did.
In a final study described by Markman, participants told to focus on a compliment’s warmth later said they were much more willing to give it than those told to focus on its phrasing.
4. Underestimating the Warmth
The fourth misjudgment is the quietest. Markman says givers slightly underestimated how warm recipients would find a compliment, a smaller gap than the others but still in the same direction.
Case Western Reserve University’s Anthony Jack, speaking in a campus news item for World Compliment Day, lists five reasons to give compliments. One is that positive emotions spread through social networks the way negative ones do, so small kindnesses can reach well beyond the person who hears them.
Parker adds a few cautions. The findings apply to appropriate, respectful comments made to strangers, and culture and familiarity can affect how accurate predictions are. For everyone else, the research suggests that hesitation is worth questioning: the compliment is probably welcome, and the wording matters less than the warmth.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Crafting Your Home.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Sachir Maharjan – CC BY-SA 4.0/Wikimedia Commons

