ESPN college football analyst Kirk Herbstreit timed his golden retriever, Peter, finishing a plate of cut-up steak at a New York City restaurant in under 17 seconds, and radio host Craig Carton called the whole scene disgusting. The back-and-forth, reported by the New York Post on Nov. 13, 2026, is the latest chapter in a running dispute over a dog who has become a fixture of Saturday television.
Herbstreit posted the stopwatch clip on Instagram. Carton answered on his radio show that Friday, saying he is not anti-dog but does not want to sit next to one at a steakhouse.
Seventeen Seconds at a Steakhouse Table
According to the Post, Herbstreit visited an NYC restaurant with Peter, the golden retriever he travels with, and shot a video of himself cutting up a steak and feeding it to the dog off the plate. A stopwatch ran on screen. By the time the plate was clean, the clock showed under 17 seconds.
In the video, Herbstreit said he wished the dog would enjoy it and go one bite at a time, as the Post quoted him. That is the joke of the clip: a dog who handles a steak dinner like a sprint. Anyone who has watched a retriever meet a food bowl knows the feeling, and a guide to Thanksgiving foods dogs should never eat from this site makes the point that the holiday table is a place where dogs need watching. People who share a home with big dogs often keep a vacuum built for pet hair handy and a few tips for traveling with a dog in mind, and Herbstreit’s setup is a high-profile version of the same routine.
The Post did not report what restaurant it was, and it did not report whether the staff or other diners reacted. New York City is a city of cramped tables and strong opinions, where a famous actor tending bar at a Yonkers pub on Halloween and a bride whose getting-ready room got a visit from Tom Brady show how a celebrity can change an ordinary room, and the question of where a dog belongs in the room has plenty of fans on each side. Visitors planning a New York meal can find ideas in a roundup of free or cheap things to do in New York City.
What Carton Said on the Air
The Post opened its story by saying Carton was mad again. On his show Friday, he said he is not anti-dog, but he does not want to go to a steakhouse and eat beside one, because in his word, it is “disgusting.” He pictured a diner turning to the right to see a perfectly cooked medium-rare steak delivered to the Herbstreit table, only to learn that it was not for any of the adults.
He also took a swipe at the filming. Carton said Herbstreit was documenting everything he does and joked that he must not act like a human being without a camera. He added that people who go out to dinner about once a week, after working hard, are looking forward to a nice meal with their spouses and another couple, not to sharing the room with a dog’s dinner.
The complaint is about restaurant atmosphere, and it joins a long line of dining debates, from an automatic 18 percent gratuity for a party of five to the question of who gets to claim a table. Home cooks who would rather skip the debate can pick up some clever kitchen tricks and serve steak at their own table. Herbstreit has not, in the Post’s coverage, answered Carton directly.
Why Peter Draws a Crowd
Peter is not an ordinary restaurant guest. Awful Announcing reported that Peter is the latest of Herbstreit’s golden retrievers to be a fixture on College GameDay and an occasional presence on Thursday Night Football, appearing more regularly after the passing of Ben, Herbstreit’s eldest golden retriever, last year.
In an appearance on SI Media with Jimmy Traina, Herbstreit described the dog’s following in glowing terms. He compared Peter to Taylor Swift in terms of college football popularity, said the entire GameDay set combined might not match it and joked that he has become just a dog handler on the road, with fans asking for pictures with Peter, according to Awful Announcing.
The Post noted that Herbstreit has traveled with Peter for the past few years after Ben died in November 2024. That background helps explain why the dog turns up in so many of the analyst’s videos, including the steak clip. A dog with that kind of audience is likely to keep showing up wherever his owner goes, and Carton’s response suggests the audience is not unanimous.
Where the Dog Belongs
Whether Peter should have been at the table is a question the Post’s report leaves open. It describes the clip, quotes Carton and notes the history. It does not report a response from the restaurant, nor does it say whether the venue allows dogs inside.
That gap matters because rules about dogs in restaurants vary by place, and customers react differently to the sight of a dog at a table. Carton’s reaction is a matter of taste, as his own words suggest. Herbstreit’s video is a matter of fun, as the stopwatch suggests. Neither is a ruling.
For now, the clip joins a long list of internet moments in which a dog wins by simply being a dog.
Get stories like this by email. Sign up for Crafting Your Home.
This article was produced with AI assistance and edited for accuracy against the sources linked above.
Image: Bobak Ha’Eri – CC BY 3.0/Wikimedia Commons
